The Board of Immigration Appeals has reversed a grant of deferral of removal under the Convention Against Torture to a Salvadoran former gang member. While acknowledging that perceived gang members are subject to widespread arrest in El Salvador, the Board stated that, “[t]he evidence the Immigration Judge relied upon does not evaluate whether there are characteristics or circumstances that make certain classes of detainees, such as deportees from the United States, any more or less likely to be victims of torture. Further, the applicant has not shown that the majority of current or former gang members detained in El Salvador are likely to suffer harm satisfying the legal definition of torture, such that he would need to show nothing more than gang affiliation and a likelihood of detention to meet his burden of proof.”
The full text of Matter of A-A-R- can be found here: